Transcripts:
In 2001, Michael Jackson released what would become his final studio album. It debuted at number one, it sold millions of copies, and yet it was seen as a failure. and the moment the king of pop truly lost his grip on the throne. It had been six years since the release of Michael's last studio album, history.
In that time, he'd become a father to two, and had faced a merciless media onslaught. Every move, every rumor, every allegation smashed across the tabloids. His public image wasn't just damaged, it had become a spectacle. Michael was still the most famous pop star on earth, but he had also become the most ridiculed.
History, half greatest hits, half angry manifesto and his first since child abuse allegations was the first sign of his dominance slipping. It sold around 20 million copies, impressive for anyone else, but for Michael it was disappointing. Bad and Dangerous had cleared 30 million nich. His 1997 remix album, though the bestselling remix album ever, sold just 6 million copies.
It seemed the world was paying less attention to the music and more to the scandals. So, when Invincible was announced, it wasn't just an album. It was a comeback, a declaration, a statement of relevance. >> What's the first word of the bridge? You try everything. Okay. Recording began in October 97 with a target release date of November 99.
Instead, the album dragged on for 4 years and wasn't finished until just 8 weeks before release. >> Of all my albums, I would say this one was the toughest cuz I was hardest on myself. >> Countless studio sessions, over 100 contributing musicians, more than 50 songs recorded, and an entire version of the album reportedly presented to his label in 99. then pretty much scrapped.
>> Uh, I wrote so many songs. I don't even want to say the number just to get to uh how many are on there? 16. Just to get to the 16 that I that I think are acceptable. >> Many songs discarded, others reworked. Some from the earlier sessions would later surface on compilations andostumous releases.
The final bill around $30 million. The longest, most expensive, most tortured recording process of Michael Jackson's career. This wasn't an artist casually making music. This was someone on a quest for sonic perfection. >> The idea is to um to take it a step forward and to innovate. I want to, you know, create do something that's totally different and unusual.
>> Michael pulled in the biggest names in R&B, including Babyface and longtime collaborator Teddy Riley. But it was one producer in particular who became the album's creative center. Rodney Jerkkins, also known as Darkshard. Oh, >> Dark Chard. >> At the time, Darkard was everywhere. The Boy Is Mine, Say My Name, It's Not Right, but It's okay.
He wasn't man enough, and countless others. His mission was clear. Push Michael into a harder, edgier, more modern lane. What made Mike tick is when he hears sounds that he that no one else uses. >> Michael's goal was even bigger. He wanted another thriller, something futuristic, something recordbreaking >> and make our own sound.
>> Mhm. >> Hit on things. We beat on things. So nobody can duplicate what we do. We make them with our own hands with we find things and we create things. And uh that's the most important thing to me to be a pioneer, be an innovator. >> On paper, Invincible had it all. Worldclass writers and producers, a Cara Santana feature fresh off his massive supernatural era, even aostumous rap from the notorious B.I.
The album wasn't supposed to fail. It was engineered not to. Almost overengineered. And that may have been the problem. Invincible arrived as a dense 77 minute 16 track record. Nearly 5 minutes per song on average. Lavish, metallic, ambitiously produced, and yet underedited, overworked, and emotionally muted.
Michael's classic albums were dynamic. Invincible felt weighed down by perfectionism, which dulled its impact. It sounded futuristic, but in a very Y2K way. Not daring, not groundbreaking, at least not in the way Michael once was. More like Michael Jackson's classic sound carefully repackaged in the early 2000s.
Slick, polished, but lacking the thrill of innovation. Experimental, sure. Pioneering, not quite. This wasn't going to define the future of pop as Michael once had. It was really just dragging him into the present. And by that point, the present had already moved on. And during this era, pop music didn't wait. The sound might have landed 12 to 18 months earlier during the glossy Max Martin boom.
But by October 2001, the landscape had already shifted. Pop and R&B were leaner, minimalist, edgier, more hip-hop driven. Michael had tried to plug in harder beats, guest rappers, Dark Char's signature polish, but he did it as a legend trying to catch up, not as a peer shaping the sound. Younger listeners didn't see him as the future.
Older fans couldn't recognize him as the past. The result, he was stuck in no man's land. Even Rodney Jerkin's signature sound, though still formidable, had transitioned from a disruptive force to a familiar industry standard, having already produced his most defining hits before Invincible. Meanwhile, the producers truly rewriting pop were the Neptunes.
The Kicker, they had submitted tracks of Invincible songs, you know, like I love you, Rock Your Body, Senorita, and Michael had passed. Those tracks reappeared a year later on Justin Timberlake's debut solo album, Justified. Critics loved the records. The public, too. >> John Mlan was his manager at the time.
We sent him pretty much all the stuff you guys are hearing on the first Justified album. That's all the Michael stuff. All but one song. They were all written for >> Michael. >> Uh Michael. John Mlan was like, "Man, Michael don't want that shit." >> The stuff that the Neptunes gave to Justin for Justified was meant for Michael Jackson.
In fact, he felt it was too generic at the time. >> The contrast is brutal. Invincible sounded expensive, calculated, and overproduced. Justified sounded agile, self assured, and forwardthinking. And in the early 2000s, that was exactly the sound pop demanded. The lead single, You Rock My World, did well on paper, top 10 in the US, number two in the UK, a big budget, slightly nonsensical video, but it wasn't seismic.
It wasn't a cultural reset like Billy Gene or Black or White. As fast as it arrived, it was gone. Invincible debuted at number one on the Billboard 200, selling 366,000 copies in its first week. Respectable, even strong, just 25,000 copies shy of history's numbers. But context matters. One week later, Britney Spears released Britney.
First week's sales 746,000, easily knocking Michael off the top spot. The center of pop gravity had shifted. visibly and then the roll out fell apart. Only two singles were officially released. After You Rock My World came Cry. Michael didn't even appear in the video. That alone tells you the campaign already had issues.
Originally, Michael wanted album opener Unbreakable as the lead single. Sony said no. It was then lined up as the second single. Then 9/11 happened. Suddenly, priorities across the industry shifted. The tone was reassessed. Cry was selected instead. Then, bizarrely, its US release was cancelled. And just like that, the momentum died.
One track still cut through. Butterflies, warm, melodic, and deeply emotive, written by Flurries Marsha Brocious, and produced by Neo Soul Maestro Andre Harris. What was it like putting that song together with him? >> A dream. >> Your vocals on there was a dream. Like >> still us together. Like we spent two weeks in the studio and I vocally produced them and it was amazing.
>> It was released to radio only. There was no video, no single. And yet it was one of the most acclaimed tracks. >> Michael Jackson Butterflies though. I mean, that was one of Michael's last greatest hits that, you know, I feel like that was the that was the Michael that we all wanted him to ride out with.
>> It hinted at what the album could have been, one built on restraint instead of spectacle, but that version of Invincible never existed. Tensions between Michael and Sony exploded. Promotion slowed. Michael interpreted this as sabotage. >> The record companies really, really do conspire against their artists.
They steal, they cheat, they do whatever they can, especially the black artists. So, I'm leaving Sony, a free agent of owning half of Sony, and they they're very angry at me because of it. So, >> the way they get revenge is to try and destroy my album. Sony store is risk management. >> If you don't have a good piece of product and it's not successful, it's not always the fault of the record company.
No tour followed and interest all but died. The release of Invincible coincided with the implosion of the Michael Jackson mystique. The public's gaze had turned toxic. He was a man overexposed and relentlessly scrutinized. His image shifting from pop diety to bewildering eccentric. That critical illusion of untouchability lay in shards.
This album was engineered not just for the charts but for cultural reclamation. A mandate to recrown the icon. Yet the goalpost had shifted. For the king of pop, anything less than global domination looked like a spectacular fail. Once his invincibility was gone, the world quickly lost interest. Today, the postmortem of invincible is more nuanced.
It is often cited as a work of excess, over long and overproduced. Yet, it's undeniably anchored by flashes of brilliance. With sales estimated around 10 million, its reputation has softened into a cult classic among his discoraphy. But symbolically, the album marks the end of Michael Jackson's a contemporary pop force.
Not because he failed, but because the rules of the industry changed faster than he could. And pop doesn't wait for anyone, not even legends. >> They build you up and then once you get there, they're so quick to tear you down. >> In 2004, Janet Jackson released her eighth studio album, Deita Joe. It debuted at number two.
It sold millions of copies worldwide. And yet it became one of the most punished albums in pop history, effectively derailing Janet's career. Not because of the music, but because of a split-second incident that would become one of the biggest national scandals of our time. Janet Jackson entered the 2000s as one of pop music's most consistent and boundary pushing artists.
She never quite reached the dominance of Madonna, Mariah, Whitney, or Seline in terms of sales or international reach, but she was critically respected, socially conscious, and a powerhouse performer. Every album, every tour, every single was executed with precision. In a landscape crowded with younger divas and emerging R&B stars, Janet's career was disciplined, ambitious, and carefully managed.
By the time 2004 arrived, her position was seemingly secure. Although Son of a Gun, the final single from her previous album, 2001's All for You, became her first single in over a decade to miss the US top 10, it was treated as a minor footnote, not a warning sign. The All for You era itself had been a success.
The title track was one of the biggest songs of 2001, broke Airplay records, and won a Grammy. In practical terms, Janet remained a major recording artist. She was still selling albums, still commanding radio and television, and still viewed by the industry as a reliable bankable pop figure. There was no narrative of collapse, no sense that her relevance was in question.
If anything, expectations for her next album were that it would perform well as the continuation of a long sustained career. That would all change on the 1st of February, 2004. It should have been a career victory lap, a global stage reinforcing her legacy as one of Pop's great performers. Instead, it became a public execution.
>> One moment, a split second decimated decades of goodwill. So, >> choose your music. >> Choose your team. >> Choose to be >> offensive, embarrassing to us and our fans, and inappropriate >> time duet, has now sparked a federal investigation. This says the woman at the center of it all, Janet Jackson. >> The so-called wardrobe malfunction triggered an outrage that was immediate, moralistic, and grotesqually uneven.
Justin Timberlake emerged largely untouched. >> Justin was emphatic. the idea was not his. >> Got in, didn't really have time to rehearse it. I mean, I was completely shocked and and appalled and I immediately covered her up. I mean, I was completely embarrassed. >> Janet Jackson became the symbol of cultural decay.
>> Will Janet be banned from the Grammys? Hi everybody, I'm Mary Hart >> and I'm Bob Goen. Her Super Bowl flash backfire. >> The media narrative hardened fast. Suddenly, she was reckless, over sexualized, and unpatriotic. The subtext was unmistakable. Race, gender, and power converging into a perfect scapegoat.
This wasn't backlash. It was retribution. >> Demet crucially, Disa Joe, her new album, arrived in an industry that had already turned against her. The album had been conceived and recorded long before the Super Bowl fallout. For the first time in years, Janet widened her creative circle beyond Jimmy Jam and Terry Lewis, bringing in multiple outside producers at scale.
Kanye West, Dallas Austin, and Scott Storch among them. It was a deliberate shift tuned into contemporary trends aimed to hold her place in a rapidly shifting pop R&B landscape. Deita Joe wasn't meant to be a retreat. It was a recalibration. Tracks like My Bay and Strawberry Bounce pushed into new rhythmic territory, while I Want You, later Grammy nominated, proved Janet still had an instinct for elegance and restraint when she chose to exercise it.
Even before release, single strategy was being debated internally. All Night Don't Stop, My Baby, and R&B Junkie were all considered as potential lead singles before the Dallas Austin produced Just a Little While was selected. a rockedged pivot design to signal evolution whilst maintaining the pop sensibilities of All for You.
But the industry closed rounds following the Super Bowl. Viacom, CBS, MTV, Infinity Broadcasting, and Clear Channel, all facing heavy FCC fines and years of litigation that would ultimately reach the Supreme Court, retaliated quietly but decisively. >> Janet Jackson was blacklisted. I am really sorry if I offended anyone.
That was truly not my intention. >> Her apology was deemed insufficient by CBS chairman Les Moonveves. Music videos vanished. Singles were frozen out. MTV, a network that had built much of his identity on Janet's image, abruptly disengaged. Multiple sources say Moonveves worked to get Jackson banned from MTV, VH1, CBS, and all Viacom owned properties.
>> The hypocrisy was glaring. MTV continued to heavily rotate sexually explicit videos by others. While Janet's comparatively restrained visuals were nowhere to be found. >> If they're going to worry about, you know, children and what children shouldn't shouldn't see, I think they should address all issues on TV.
I think there's a lot of violence on television as well and there's a lot of hypocrisy about beating up on Janet Jackson and not a lot of other things that children um um have access to. >> An Associated Press report noted the eerie silence. A superstar honored as MTV's inaugural icon just 3 years earlier suddenly erased.
Just a little while initially showed real promise. Early AirPlay reports were strong. In some formats, it was being added more aggressively than 2004's biggest hit, Ushers. Yeah. But once the blacklist took effect, the song virtually disappeared from radio rotation without explanation. Follow-up singles fed no better.
All Night Don't Stop became a club staple and topped the US dance chart. The Kanye produced I want you found an audience on urban radio and earned Grammy recognition. But neither could cross into mainstream without institutional support. By the time promotional single R&B Junkie arrived, the campaign was already beyond saving.
Reviews were mixed. Some critics praised the production and the album's sonic ambition. Others found it vocally poor, overly sexual, and lacking the cohesion of the Velvet Road or All for You. The very thing that made the album adventurous, its multi-producer sprawl, also made it feel diffuse. Janet at times seemed to disappear into the production rather than command it.
Commercially, the numbers told a complicated story. Dita Joe debuted at number two in the US with approximately 381,000 copies sold, the second biggest opening week of Janet's career. In isolation, that's a success. In context, it was a downturn. All for You had opened with over 600,000 copies just three years earlier and gone on to sell more than double Demeta Joe's total.
For the first time in two decades, Janet failed to debut at number one. The album eventually went platinum in the US and sold over 3 million copies worldwide, respectable by any standard, especially in an era increasingly disrupted by file sharing and music piracy. But for Janet Jackson, it was framed as a failure.
>> When you released Dita Joe, it was a couple of years ago. It the sales were not Janet Jackson type numbers. >> Um, how much of that do you think was the fallout from the fact it came out kind of in the middle of Michael's trial for child molestation and the whole Super Bowl thing that you don't want to talk about? >> I I truly don't know.
It was still a platinum album, but you know, it's so funny how they they it just because it which is success. And then came the final indignity. For the first time since 1989's Rhythm Nation, Janet did not tour to support a studio album. No redemption arc, no victory lap, no chance to reclaim the narrative. Whether Deme Joe would have become a true commercial resurgence without the Super Bowl fallout remains a matter of hindsight.
Some believe it could have arrivaled or even surpassed All for You, producing multiple hit singles in a strong international showing. Others might argue that beneath the surface, the cultural tide was already shifting. Newer stars were commanding attention. Pop and R&B were recalibrating. And Janet's era of unquestioned dominance may have been naturally softening, even if the industry hadn't yet acknowledged it.
What's undeniable is this. Deita Joe was never allowed to fail or succeed on its own terms. >> It wasn't rejected by the audiences so much as abandoned by the industry. >> In hindsight, it stands as one of pop's clearest examples of institutional punishment masquerading as market response. >> A reminder that in pop music, scandal doesn't just derail careers, it rewrites them.
They build you up and then once you get there, they're so quick to tear you down. >> Madonna, >> ladies and gentlemen, I give you Madonna. In 2003, Madonna was still the world's ultimate female pop star. But the musical landscape was moving fast and a new generation was circling for her crown.
That year would see her release her ninth studio album, American Life. Unabashedly political, it would become one of the most polarizing, controversial, and unsuccessful albums of her career, threatening her reign as the once undisputed queen of pop. Despite being 20 years into her career, Madonna had managed the near impossible. She had remained relevant in pop culture, specifically the world of music.
Through many reinventions, her star had stayed bright where others had faded. A pop icon in every sense. Just 5 years earlier in 1998, Ray of Light had won her four Grammys and restored her critical credibility. 2000's music had scored her a US number one album for the first time in over a decade, selling 420,000 copies in its first week.
Commercially, creatively, and culturally, Madonna was still a force to be reckoned with. And yet, the world had shifted under her feet. Britney, MSync, Eminem, and the Backstreet Boys were now dominating first week sales, some breaking records, surpassing a million copies in days. Pop had grown younger, flashier, and more aggressive.
Madonna was still massively successful, but suddenly she wasn't untouchable. She was now competing with a generation of stars shaping a new era. >> I'm not claiming that I'm going to appeal to the same people that, you know, Christina Aguilera or Britney Piers are going to appeal to. And I'm not I'm not trying to.
I'm doing what I want to do. >> Would you like to Would you like those 17-year-olds to buy your records? I would. You're the age of their parents, basically. >> Great. For her next album, her team reunited with Mir Ways, the French producer behind music, aiming to continue pushing her into experimental electronica territory. >> He's got a kind of a sad, dark sensibility, and we like the juxiposition of of uh up music and kind of sad lyrics. I like the combination.
>> They wanted Madonna to stay ahead of the curve to create a record that was innovative, bold, and unmistakably hers. With her recent chart success, the stakes couldn't have been higher. Fans and critics alike expected another reinvention, something daring, something culturally seismic, and seemingly Madonna was ready to push the envelope once again.
But in the 3 years since the release of music, the world had changed. American life was conceived in a post 911 America, a nation reeling from tragedy and united in an unprecedented wave of nationalism. Madonna's vision was ambitious, a politically charged, introspective album that questioned fame, power, and American values.
The lead single, American Life, was meant to shock, provoke, and spark conversation. Its original video depicted Madonna throwing a hand grenade at a George Bush lookalike during a war themed fashion show. A visual metaphor for her disillusionment with politics, materialism, and celebrity culture, as well as her opposition to the Bush administration.
But the timing was catastrophic. The US was a wash in patriotism. War drums were beating. Madonna's protest wasn't just unpopular. It was dangerous. Madonna is certain to be accused of trying to cash in on the war in Iraq, and industry insiders believe the timing of the video may mean it's just too controversial.
Warner Brothers pulled the video days before release, replacing it with a watered down version. The controversy became the story. The song became secondary, and the music itself didn't make things easier. American life departed from the spiritual complexity of Ray of Light and the danceorientated music. Volkronic and sonic tension sat at the core of the production, pairing stripped back acoustic elements with rigid synthetically treated beats.
Madonna even wrapped on the title track, awkwardly rhyming latte with shottΓ© and Mini Cooper with super duper. >> I'm drinking a soy latte. I get a double shotte. It goes right through my vate and you know I'm satisfied. >> Which inevitably became full of for ridicule. Sure, it was creative, fearless, and uncompromising, but for many, it was alienating.
Listeners expecting a return to the musical sensibilities of her previous albums were confronted with something jarring, cerebral, and challenging. Public perception didn't help. By this point, Donna was living in the UK, exploring Cabala, cultivating an image that many critics dismissed as contrived, and performing stunts designed to shock.
Of course, Madonna had always pushed buttons, but her fame had grown so enormous that her attempts at social commentary now carried a whiff of arrogance. Critics questioned whether she had the credibility to rail against American consumerism, and mainstream audiences struggled to connect. because it sounds a little bit like Madonna.
You're someone who's benefited from celebrity as much as anyone has and enjoyed it. >> Benefited and but I've also seen the other side of >> Okay. But you enjoyed the ride and now it seems at 40ome years old you're looking back and saying celebrity bull. >> Um to a certain extent I am. >> Even the single strategy faulted.
American life was the bold confrontational kickoff, but too complex and politically charged for mainstream radio. Adono explored her power, wealth, and existential dissatisfaction. Though at times it came across as her complaining about her privilege. Acoustic strums, glitch electronics, and processed beats collided, creating jagged textures and off-kilter beats.
Where frozen and music balanced innovation with clear hooks, American Life challenged listeners expectations, it demanded focus and patience instead of instant gratification, a risky move in a genre built on escapism. After the video debacle, McDonald's labeled unpatriotic and US radio stations heavily consolidated under conservative owned Clear Channel largely blacklisted the track.
The second single, Hollywood, intended as a more accessible guitar-lled dance track, arrived too late to regain momentum, even with the provocative video. Further singles, Nothing Fails and Love Profusion, struggled to chart. Even her infamous 2003 VMAs performance couldn't save the album. On paper, Madonna had the tools to dominate.
Innovation, star power, a loyal fan base. In reality, the album collided with politics, the media, and cultural timing in ways she hadn't anticipated. American life was not just a commercial experiment. It was a social experiment, and it misfired. >> The New York Times article basically was saying, Madonna, >> I'm irrelevant.
>> That you're going to have a difficult time from now on connecting to the target audience that buys the CDs. And in the papers this morning, they're making much of the fact that Madonna is top of the charts or going to the top of the charts with her album, but pointing out that her single is founding at number 27.
The album debuted at number one in the US, selling 241,000 copies in its first week. Solid, yes, but compared to the pop landscape at the time, it was underwhelming in a market now dominated by younger stars. Britney's album, In the Zone, released later that same year, sold 608,000 copies first week and went on to sell more than double the 5 million copies American Life sold in total.
And compared to Ray of Light's 16 million total and music's 11 million total, it was a big downward shift. Critical reception was polarized. Fans were divided. Is this Madonna album being perceived as a success? because it sold I think 24100,000 copies compared to 420 music 371 Ray of Light. >> The fact is it's got to number one. So of course that immediately is cued us for the album but it shows that people are buying the album instead of the single.
It probably is an indication of the kind of audience she has these days. >> Madonna still toured. The reinvention world tour dazzled and reminded the world why she was a performer without equal. But the album itself never regained traction. It was a stark reminder. Even the most legendary artists could misread the moment. A changing industry, politics, and outward perception could outweigh decades of dominance.
Time has softened the perception of American life. Tracks like Intervention, Nothing Fails, and Nobody Knows Me have endured and have been celebrated in live performances and embraced by devoted fans. Critics increasingly view the album as honest, underappreciated, and ahead of its time.
Yet, in 2003, it just didn't connect. Madonna's instincts felt out of step with the mainstream. Two years later, Confessions on the Dance floor would restore her as a global pop force, leaning into escapism, dance floor perfection, and infectious energy. American life, by contrast, stands as a cautionary tale. A rare glimpse of vulnerability, artistic risk, and a pop legend testing the limits of her fame, only to find that even queens can stumble.
