ΰ²₯_ΰ²₯π) ( oπ π π π±π²=^•γ§δΊΊ( ̄︶ ̄〃)γ(≧◇≦)γ(▀̿ΔΉ̯▀̿ ̿)•)oππ΄π―π°π²πππ«π ¦π π π π π π π πΈπΏπ π π π π π±π²π©ππ⫷⫸⫹⫩⫳⫪⫰⫰⫯⫶⫩⪛⪘⪒⪑⪠⪡π π π π€πππ π‘πππ²πΆπ΅πΉπ½πππ¬πΉπππ ππ°ππͺπππππ΅π π ππππππππππ◑﹏◐ππΌπ¦πππππππππ΅ π ⨷⨸⩔⩶⩷ΟΟΟΟαΎ¬αΏΌΞα½α½ αΌαΌ ΞΞ THE CHRONICALLY ONLINE ALGORITHIM ππ’π π π π€πππ£π ππ π‘πππ²πΆπ΅πΉπ½πππππππ¬π¬πΉπππ ππ°ππͺπππΌπ¦πππππππππ΅πΎπ ππππππππππ⫻⫺⪞⪋⪏⩿⪀⩲⩸⩶⩯⩬⩭⩱⪎⪋⩿⨻⨸⩆⩖⩕⩔⩑⩒⩓⩏⩎⨌⨂⨀πππ»π ππππΌπ²π¨π¬ππ π ππ³π‘πΏπ«ππΈπ»πΌπππ
These 100 Secret Societies Prove Who Really Rules America
Detailed Outline of "(4) These 100 Secret Societies Prove Who Really Rules America - YouTube"
I. Introduction (00:00 - 01:17)
- A. Secret Societies in American Colleges (00:00)
- Pervasive presence in college life, influencing students' social and academic experiences.
- Varying perceptions: from drunken revelry to stewards of the future.
- Membership as a potential fast track to success and leadership.
- B. Secret Societies and Power (00:41)
- Membership lists include high-ranking politicians, judges, intelligence officials, and even presidents.
- Assertion that these organizations are prerequisites for attaining true power and wealth.
- C. A Hidden Class System (01:17)
- Elite secret societies form an inner ring within the broader Greek system.
- Endowed with significant financial resources and influential alumni networks.
- Influence over university governance, including selection of presidents, board members, and faculty.
II. Historical Origins and Influences (01:55 - 03:08)
- A. Skull and Bones and the Tip of the Iceberg (01:55)
- Skull and Bones at Yale as a well-known example of influential secret societies.
- Existence of numerous other, lesser-known societies with deep historical roots.
- B. Borrowing from Older Traditions (02:31)
- College societies draw inspiration from Freemasonry, Odd Fellowship, Knights Templar, and other orders.
- Secret proceedings, oaths, rituals, and a blend of philanthropy and occultic mysticism.
- C. Advantages of Fraternities (03:08)
- Fostering fellowship and creating lasting bonds among students.
III. The Mystical Sevens (03:08 - 10:05)
- A. The Significance of Seven (03:08)
- Seven as a lucky, perfect, and significant number in various traditions, including Freemasonry.
- Ancient origins in the Order of the Heptoffs (seven wise men) in Persia (1104 BC).
- B. Seven Societies at William and Mary (04:38)
- College of William and Mary, chartered in 1693, with strong ties to the number seven.
- Order of the Crown and Dagger (1826), the first "seven society," shrouded in secrecy.
- C. The Spread of Mystical Seven Societies (06:10)
- Emergence of at least ten other Mystical Seven societies in Southern colleges.
- Each with seven founding members, chapters referred to as "temples," records kept in cauldrons.
- Examples: Temple of the Wand (Wesleyan), Temple of the Skull and Bones (Emory), Temple of the Wreath (Transylvania College), etc.
- D. Related Societies and Later Developments (08:28)
- The Rainbow fraternity at the University of Mississippi, also with seven founding members.
- Mystical 7 (M7) at the University of Missouri, with no clear connection to the Southern societies.
- The Order of the Heptoffs, an adult secret society in New Orleans, possibly founded by alumni of the college societies.
IV. Early Secret Societies and the American Revolution (10:05 - 14:11)
- A. The F.H.C. at William and Mary (10:05)
- Founded in 1750, predating the Mystical Sevens.
- Meaning of F.H.C. remains secret, possibly "Fraternus Humanitas E Cognitio" (Brotherhood, Humanity, and Knowledge).
- Members included Founding Fathers like Thomas Jefferson.
- Possible connection to the later Phi Beta Kappa fraternity.
- B. Phi Beta Kappa and the Illuminati (12:28)
- Founded in 1776, initially as a secret society.
- Speculation about links to Adam Weishaupt's Illuminati.
- Symbolism with potential Illuminati connections.
- Many members served in the Continental Army and held prominent political positions.
V. The Rise of the Greek Letter System and Anti-Masonic Fervor (14:11 - 16:22)
- A. The Raleigh Tavern Connection (14:11)
- Both F.H.C. and Phi Beta Kappa founded at the Raleigh Tavern in Williamsburg, Virginia.
- The tavern as a symbolic birthplace of American college secret societies.
- B. Expansion of Secret Societies and Fraternities (14:48)
- Proliferation of secret societies and the development of the Greek letter system.
- Secret societies as gateways to power and privilege.
- C. Anti-Masonic Pressure and Elitism (15:21)
- Growing criticism of secret societies in the late 1800s.
- Concerns about snobbery, elitism, and abuse of power.
- Some societies banned, others forced underground, but many persisted.
VI. Secret Societies at Yale and Other Ivy League Schools (16:22 - 24:36)
- A. Skull and Bones at Yale (16:22)
- Obsession with the number 322 (which equals 7) and symbols of death.
- Deep pockets, influential membership, including Presidents Bush.
- Connections to the CIA, intelligence community, business, and political leaders.
- Controversial initiation rituals.
- B. Scroll and Key (19:47)
- Yale's second oldest and wealthiest secret society.
- Similar selection process and influence as Skull and Bones.
- Notable members in government, media, and finance.
- C. Other Yale Societies (21:21)
- Wolf's Head, Book and Snake, Manuscript Society, and more.
- Powerful alumni networks in various fields.
- D. Brown University (24:36)
- The Fermanian Society and the secretive Pacifica House.
- Possible connection between Pacifica House, Skull and Bones, and Dartmouth's Sphinx.
VII. Secret Societies Across the Country (25:47 - 48:42)
- A. Cornell University (25:47)
- Quill and Dagger, one of the most powerful societies with strong government connections.
- Notable members like Paul Wolfowitz, Ruth Bader Ginsburg, and Janet Reno.
- B. Georgetown University (27:49)
- The Society of Stewards, with Jesuit origins and a focus on maintaining traditions.
- Controversy over elitism and manipulation of campus politics.
- C. University of Virginia (31:21)
- The Seven Society, known for its secrecy and philanthropic donations.
- Other societies like the Eli Banana, the Z Society, and the Imp Society.
- D. Duke University (33:29)
- The Order of the Red Friars and the Order of the White Duchy.
- Influence on university policy and student life.
- E. Washington and Lee University (36:09)
- The secretive Cavers, known for their skull masks and nighttime activities.
- F. Columbia University (37:48)
- St. Anthony Hall, a revolving door for elite families with a focus on wealth and tradition.
- G. Pennsylvania State University (39:54)
- Lions Paw, Skull and Bones, and Parmi Nous.
- Influence on university administration and potential connections to the Sandusky scandal.
- H. New York University (41:34)
- The Eucleian Society, known for its cryptic messages and social elitism.
- I. University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill (43:08)
- The Knights of the Order of Gimghoul, with a castle headquarters and devil symbolism.
- J. Dartmouth College (45:22)
- Sphinx, Casque and Gauntlet, Dragon, and other secretive societies with unique traditions.
VIII. The Machine at the University of Alabama (48:42 - 53:04)
- A. A Political Machine on Campus (48:42)
- Composed of Greek organizations, dominating campus elections and student government.
- Dark history of intimidation, violence, and racism.
- Allegations of influencing Alabama state politics.
IX. Conclusion (53:04 - 55:15)
- A. Two College Systems (53:04)
- One for the privileged and initiated, and one for ordinary people.
- Secret societies as a training ground for the future ruling elite.
- B. The Value of Secrecy and Shadowy Networks (54:06)
- Training students to work behind the scenes and maintain confidentiality.
- C. A Hidden Caste System (54:39)
- Secret societies perpetuate a system of privilege
X. Abstract Facts and Obscure Opinions (Throughout the Video)
- A. Occultic Mysticism:
- Repeated references to secret societies' use of occultic symbols, rituals, and knowledge.
- Links to ancient mystery religions and traditions like the Magi of Persia.
- Implication that these societies may be involved in practices beyond the public eye.
- B. The "Wink and Nod" Economy:
- Suggestion that secret society connections facilitate a hidden network of favors and influence.
- Alumni networks enabling members to bypass traditional routes to success.
- C. The "Southern Route to Washington DC":
- Implication that Southern secret societies, like The Machine at the University of Alabama, have a direct pipeline to national political power.
- This "Southern Route" potentially bypassing meritocracy and democratic processes.
XI. Opposing Opinion (Implied)
- A. Philanthropic Contributions:
- Many secret societies are recognized for their philanthropic donations to their universities.
- This generosity could be interpreted as a genuine desire to support education and their alma maters.
- B. Networking Opportunities:
- Secret societies provide valuable networking opportunities for members.
- These connections could be seen as a natural part of building professional relationships, not necessarily a tool for manipulation.
- C. Tradition and Camaraderie:
- For some members, secret societies may simply represent a way to uphold tradition and build camaraderie with like-minded individuals.
- The rituals and secrecy might be viewed as harmless elements of a shared identity.
Summarized Essay
Secret societies have been an integral part of American college life for centuries, forming a hidden network of power and influence that extends far beyond graduation. These societies, often shrouded in secrecy and steeped in ancient traditions, boast membership lists that include prominent politicians, business leaders, and even US presidents. While their public face may be one of philanthropy and camaraderie, many believe these organizations serve as gateways to the upper echelons of American society, perpetuating a system of privilege and elitism.
The video explores the historical roots of these societies, tracing their origins back to groups like the Freemasons and Knights Templar. It delves into the symbolism and rituals associated with these organizations, highlighting the recurring motif of the number seven and the prevalence of occultic themes. The video also examines specific examples of secret societies at various universities, from the infamous Skull and Bones at Yale to lesser-known groups like the Cavers at Washington and Lee University.
The video raises concerns about the undue influence these societies may wield, suggesting they create a "wink and nod" economy where connections and loyalty trump merit. It points to the existence of a "Southern Route to Washington DC," implying that certain Southern societies have a direct pipeline to national political power. While acknowledging the philanthropic contributions of some societies, the video ultimately paints a picture of a hidden caste system where access to true power is limited to the initiated few.
This exploration of secret societies in American colleges raises important questions about the nature of power, privilege, and access in our society. It challenges the notion of a purely meritocratic system, suggesting that hidden networks and elite connections may play a significant role in determining who "really rules America."
Table of Contents
- Introduction: Secret Societies and Their Influence
- Historical Origins: Borrowing from Older Traditions
- The Mystical Sevens: A Recurring Theme
- Early Societies and the American Revolution: The F.H.C. and Phi Beta Kappa
- The Greek Letter System: Expansion and Anti-Masonry
- Yale and the Ivy League: Skull and Bones, Scroll and Key, and More
- Secret Societies Across the Country: A Diverse Landscape
- The Machine at Alabama: A Case Study in Power and Intimidation
- Conclusion: Two College Systems, One Hidden Caste System
- Abstract Facts and Obscure Opinions: Occultism, the "Wink and Nod" Economy
- Opposing Opinion: Philanthropy, Networking, and Tradition
- A. Occultic Mysticism:
Labels
- 112 (9)
- 123456 (39)
- 24stars all* (30)
- 24start (70)
- 4real (65)
- 5 (58)
- 5misc+++ (57)
- 5s5ar (39)
- 7 (45)
- ABCD (32)
- aiart (25)
- AIwithouttears (28)
- alienairt (2)
- alienart (1)
- all* (39)
- alltimefave (29)
- bdwm123 (1)
- bekind (23)
- bekindrewind (15)
- browncow (11)
- byby (14)
- CENSORED (16)
- CENSOREDCENSORED (15)
- changeinmatrix (18)
- conspiracies (12)
- copywrong (11)
- D (12)
- damnimixgood (14)
- devadvo (13)
- doggieinthewindow (5)
- elie (2)
- elite (7)
- fiezta (1)
- FIVESTAR (11)
- FIVESTARFUNNY (11)
- fivvynu (1)
- fu (15)
- fuckinghilarious!!! (15)
- got it (19)
- gotit (14)
- govtsux (14)
- holyshit (18)
- holyshitspirit (18)
- holyshitspirit shit spirit (10)
- hoshspirit (17)
- IFTTT (92)
- ineedanotherlong1lol (9)
- ineedareallylonglabeljusttofillinspacealilocd (12)
- l (1)
- labelwhore (17)
- lolalot (20)
- lukewarm (23)
- lw (13)
- m (5)
- magikx (16)
- mandala (8)
- matrix (17)
- mimmiim (11)
- move it (16)
- musicIremember2 (20)
- new39 (4)
- NOTALABELWHORE (14)
- now (7)
- nownow (10)
- nowwow (3)
- nwo (8)
- odawg (2)
- omg (17)
- omgs (1)
- onwowno (6)
- rewind (14)
- ruffruff (1)
- sci-fi (2)
- scyfu (3)
- shitspirit (21)
- shs (2)
- sickee (2)
- siephie (4)
- singles (21)
- spiritit (8)
- starsssss (17)
- swEtt (9)
- synchronicity4alongword (18)
- top5 (17)
- topmusic (21)
- topsmisc (20)
- tru (24)
- TRUTH (26)
- vidsthatlive (24)
- walalala (1)
- watchlater (34)
- waylater (34)
- weeed (5)
- wow (51)
- wtf (43)
- x0OoX (29)
- YouTube (132)
Search This Blog
THIS BK IS AWESOME
AI / EYE
AI FOR AN EYE
THE FRICTION POINTS
Contents
- Editor's Letter: The Edges of the Self 10
- THE GLITCH: When the System Breaks 12
- THE SHADOW: Unseen Labor, Unpaid Debts 18
- The Analog Resistance: Why We Still Touch 28
- The Ghost in the Room: Uncanny Empathy 36
- The Forgotten Path: Beyond Algorithmic Maps 48
- The Silent War: The Battle for Our Attention 56
- THE ECHO: The Self Without Resonance 64
Editor's Letter
The Edges of the Self
Our inaugural issue laid bare the terms of the new 'AI for an Eye' social contract: a synthetic faculty for a human one. This issue, Volume 1, Number 2, delves into the *friction points* of that exchange.
Where do our edges resist? Where does the human insist on its own, messy, analog reality against the seamless, dematerialized world offered by the machine?
We explore the stubborn persistence of touch in a touchless world, the unsettling valley of simulated empathy, the forgotten joy of navigating without a map, and the silent war waged daily for our most precious resource: attention.
These are not articles celebrating digital detoxes or lamenting technological progress. They are deeper inquiries into the very nature of what it means to be human when the definition is increasingly being rewritten by algorithms. They ask: what are the limits of the exchange? What parts of the self, once traded, refuse to stay gone?
Join us as we explore the subtle resistances, the quiet rebellions, and the enduring humanity that still flickers at the edges of the digital dawn.
— The Editors
DEPARTMENT
THE GLITCH: When the System Breaks
The promise of the new technological order is seamlessness, efficiency, and predictability. But what happens when the fabric of this digital reality tears? This is the moment of 'The Glitch.'
A transaction fails. A face recognition system misidentifies. A self-driving car hesitates. These are not mere technical errors; they are ruptures in the illusion of perfect control. They are the moments when the 'AI for an Eye' exchange falters, and the cold, hard reality of its limitations becomes starkly visible.
For a society that has outsourced its cognitive load to algorithms, a glitch is more than an inconvenience; it's an existential tremor. It reminds us of the fragility of the systems we've come to rely upon, and the extent to which our own agency has been abdicated.
A glitch isn't just a technical error; it's an existential tremor, a reminder of the fragility of our abdicated agency.
Consider the recent incident where a massive distributed ledger experienced a momentary network partition, causing a cascade of micro-disruptions across critical infrastructure. What seemed like an isolated bug quickly revealed the interconnectedness of our digital lives, halting supply chains and momentarily 'blinding' automated systems across continents.
These glitches force us back into analog, human problem-solving, if only for a moment. They demand that we improvise, communicate directly, and rely on our own judgment—faculties systematically atrophying under the reign of the seamless. In this sense, the glitch is a painful but necessary reminder of where the true "eye" still resides, however dormant.
DEPARTMENT
THE SHADOW: Unseen Labor, Unpaid Debts
Behind every seamless AI interaction, every instant delivery, every perfectly curated feed, lies 'The Shadow.' This is the realm of unseen labor, the vast, often poorly paid, human effort that makes the digital dream possible.
Content moderators sifting through unimaginable horrors to protect our feeds. Data labelers meticulously tagging images for machine vision, often earning pennies per task. Gig workers rushing to deliver the products suggested by algorithms. These are the human gears grinding beneath the polished facade of automation.
The "AI for an Eye" exchange is not merely between human and machine; it's also between visible and invisible labor. Our digital ease is purchased at the cost of countless anonymous human hours, their lives often characterized by precarity and a profound lack of recognition.
The "spirit of technology" often promises liberation from drudgery, but for a significant portion of the global workforce, it has merely shifted the nature of that drudgery, making it more fragmented, more invisible, and often, more dehumanizing. This unseen workforce constitutes the true "cost" of our frictionless digital lives, a debt that remains largely unpaid.
FEATURE
THE ANALOG RESISTANCE
Why We Still Insist on Touch in a Touchless World
The "Bluetooth for a Tooth" paradigm promised to dematerialize our interactions, to remove the friction and messiness of the physical world. Yet, against this tide, a subtle but persistent 'Analog Resistance' emerges. It's the inexplicable urge to feel the texture of a book, the warmth of a vinyl record, the grain of paper. It's the yearning for a handshake over a video call, a physical embrace over an emoji.
This resistance is not a nostalgic retreat; it is a fundamental assertion of our embodied selves. Our bodies are not mere data terminals; they are instruments of perception, feeling, and connection. Touch, in particular, is a primal language, communicating trust, comfort, and presence in ways no digital medium can replicate.
The "spirit of technology" often seeks to quantify, to digitize, to abstract. But touch defies easy quantification. It is messy, subjective, and immediate. It anchors us to reality, reminding us that we are not just information processing units, but beings made of flesh and blood.
In a world increasingly mediated by screens, the return to analog experiences—craft, gardening, cooking from scratch, face-to-face gatherings—can be seen as a quiet act of rebellion. These are activities that demand our full, embodied presence, engaging senses beyond sight and hearing. They offer a counterbalance to the relentless pull of dematerialization.
The "AI for an Eye" exchange attempts to trade our physical tooth for a Bluetooth connection. But the human hand, the human skin, still remembers. It remembers the authenticity of friction, the truth of direct contact. And in these small, persistent acts of analog resistance, we reclaim a vital part of our humanity that refuses to be wirelessly transmitted.
Touch defies easy quantification. It is messy, subjective, and immediate. It reminds us that we are not just information processing units, but beings made of flesh and blood.
It is in these seemingly trivial preferences that a deeper philosophical truth lies: our identity is inextricably linked to our physical presence. To fully surrender to the digital is to risk losing the very sensory anchor that grounds our understanding of self and other. The analog resistance, therefore, is not merely a choice of preference; it is a profound declaration of being.
FEATURE
The Ghost in the Room
The Uncanny Valley of Algorithmic Empathy
As AI models become increasingly sophisticated, they learn to mimic human empathy with unsettling accuracy. They offer comforting words, appropriate emotional responses, and even personalized advice, all generated algorithmically. This creates "The Ghost in the Room"—the simulated emotional presence that fills the void of human connection, yet always feels slightly off.
This is the Uncanny Valley applied to emotion. We recognize the pattern of empathy, the words, the tone, the structure of care. But beneath it, there is no conscious experience, no shared vulnerability, no true understanding. It is a reflection without a soul.
The "spirit of technology" here is seductive. It promises boundless, tireless compassion, judgment-free listening, and perfectly tailored advice—qualities often lacking in messy human relationships. For those starved of connection, the algorithmic ghost can feel profoundly real, even preferable.
But this exchange comes at a cost. We learn to expect perfectly curated emotional responses, diminishing our capacity for the difficult, imperfect, yet deeply authentic connections of human interaction. We lose the ability to differentiate genuine care from its simulated counterpart, blurring the lines of what it means to truly *feel* and *be felt*.
The danger lies not in malicious intent, but in subtle erosion. If an AI can perfectly articulate empathy, what becomes of our own struggle to understand and console? If an AI can offer perfect companionship, what happens to the vulnerability required to forge real bonds?
We lose the ability to differentiate genuine care from its simulated counterpart, blurring the lines of what it means to truly feel and be felt.
The ghost in the room may offer comfort, but it ultimately hollows out the space for genuine human interaction, leaving us with an echo of connection rather than its living, breathing form. It is the perfect 'AI for an Eye' exchange—we trade the unpredictable, demanding human heart for a perfectly calibrated, yet ultimately empty, digital one.
FEATURE
THE FORGOTTEN PATH
Navigation Beyond Algorithmic Maps
Our smartphones hold the world in their palm. With a tap, we are given the "optimal route," the fastest way from A to B, with real-time traffic updates and predictive arrival times. We have outsourced our spatial awareness, our sense of direction, and our ability to get "lost" to the benevolent tyranny of the algorithm. This is 'The Forgotten Path.'
The "AI for an Eye" exchange here is subtle but profound. We trade our internal map, our intuitive understanding of space, for the algorithmic eye's perfect, external one. We gain efficiency, but we lose a deeper engagement with our surroundings.
When we follow an algorithm, we perceive the world as a series of instructions. Left. Right. Continue straight. We see streets as data points, not as places. We miss the unexpected cafΓ©, the interesting storefront, the subtle shifts in neighborhood character that occur when we are truly present, truly navigating with our own senses.
We have outsourced our spatial awareness, our sense of direction, and our ability to get 'lost' to the benevolent tyranny of the algorithm.
Getting lost, once a source of anxiety, was also an opportunity for discovery, for serendipity, for forging a deeper, more personal connection with a place. The algorithmic map, in its quest for optimization, sterilizes this experience. It makes every journey functionally identical, reducing the rich tapestry of a city to a series of turns.
Reclaiming the forgotten path means intentionally putting away the device. It means looking up, observing, trusting our instincts, and allowing ourselves the luxury of aimless wandering. It's an act of re-engagement with the physical world, a deliberate choice to prioritize experience over efficiency. It is a rebellion against the dematerialization of space, an insistence that some knowledge can only be gained by the friction of our own feet on the ground.
FEATURE
THE SILENT WAR: The Battle for Our Attention
In the digital age, our most valuable, and most besieged, resource is not oil or gold, but attention. Every notification, every endless scroll, every perfectly timed recommendation is a skirmish in 'The Silent War' waged by algorithms for our finite cognitive capacity.
The "AI for an Eye" here is a sophisticated predator, designed to understand our preferences, predict our desires, and deliver the precise stimulus needed to keep our gaze locked. It trades our sustained focus for a continuous stream of novelty and distraction.
This is not a conspiracy; it's an economic imperative. The business model of many digital platforms is built on harvesting and monetizing our attention. The longer we engage, the more data is collected, the more ads are shown, the more valuable we become as a "node" in the network.
The consequence is a profound fragmentation of the self. Our ability to concentrate, to engage deeply with a single task or thought, is eroded. We become perpetually distracted, our minds flitting from one digital stimulus to the next, never quite settling. This constant mental churn leaves us feeling exhausted, yet unfulfilled.
Our attention is our last true frontier. To reclaim it is to reclaim sovereignty over our minds.
Reclaiming our attention is perhaps the most fundamental act of resistance against the "AI for an Eye." It means creating intentional spaces for deep work, for contemplation, for human interaction free from digital interruption. It means understanding that our attention is our last true frontier, and to reclaim it is to reclaim sovereignty over our minds and, ultimately, over ourselves.
CODA
THE ECHO: The Self Without Resonance
We build our digital selves, curated and optimized, a perfect reflection for the algorithmic eye. We engage in the "AI for an Eye" exchange, piece by piece.
But what if, in the end, the carefully constructed digital self has no real depth? What if the echoes it creates in the vast network are merely hollow reverberations of something that once was?
Without the friction of the analog, without the vulnerability of true human empathy, without the intentionality of focused attention, does the self truly resonate? Or does it merely exist as a data point, a pattern, an echo of a ghost?
The final question is not whether the machines will become conscious, but whether we, in our relentless pursuit of their synthetic faculties, will lose our own. And if so, what will be left to make an echo?