5 Disturbing Ideas About Reality I Found in the Internet's Strangest Corners
Introduction: Seeing Patterns in the Static
There's a unique state of mind that comes from falling down an internet rabbit hole. One moment you're reading the plot summary of a forgotten sci-fi novel, the next you're watching a conspiracy documentary about secret societies, and an hour later you're parsing a celebrity biography. The inputs are chaotic, a jumble of modern stories, myths, and accusations that feel completely unrelated. But if you spend enough time in the digital static, patterns begin to emerge from the noise.
By looking at these disparate modern stories together—treating them as a kind of digital folklore—unsettling but profound themes about our collective anxieties begin to crystallize. These aren't ancient myths about gods and monsters, but new ones about technology, identity, and control. They speak to a deep-seated fear that the reality we take for granted is far more fragile than we imagine. This post distills five of the most surprising and impactful of these recurring ideas, synthesized from the internet's strangest corners.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
1. Your Entire Existence Could Be Deleted
The idea that your identity—your history, your accomplishments, your very existence in the minds of others—is not guaranteed and can be erased is a uniquely modern terror. The most chilling depiction of this comes from Philip K. Dick's novel Flow My Tears, the Policeman Said. Its protagonist, Jason Taverner, is a world-famous TV star with an audience of thirty million. He goes to sleep a celebrity and wakes up a ghost.
In this new reality, no record of him exists. His calls to his agent and lawyer are met with confusion; they have no memory of him. He searches the newspaper for his own advertisements and finds nothing. The official records are no better. After discovering that even his birth isn't on file, his internal monologue captures the pure horror of the situation:
I don't exist, he said to himself. There is no Jason Taverner. There never was and there never will be. The hell with my career; I just want to live.
This literal erasure of a public figure finds a metaphorical echo in another of Dick's works, A Scanner Darkly. An undercover agent, known as Fred, becomes addicted to the very drug he's supposed to be tracking, "Substance D." The addiction splinters his mind to the point where he is eventually assigned to surveil his own civilian identity, Bob Arctor. This leads to what the book's psychological evaluators call a "competition phenomenon" between the two hemispheres of his brain, a civil war within his own consciousness that effectively deletes his former self. The evaluators explain the phenomenon with an analogy: “It's as if you have two fuel gauges on your car. They're studying the same amount of fuel, but one says your tank is full, the other registers empty.”
Both stories tap into the same disturbing possibility: that our identity is not an internal, inalienable fact, but a fragile consensus held in the minds of others and the bits of data systems. And that consensus can be revoked at any moment, without warning or explanation.
2. The Ultimate Punishment Isn't Death, It's a Cursed Survival
We tend to see existence and extinction as a simple binary, where survival is always the preferred outcome. But some narratives propose a chilling counter-argument: that survival can be a punishment worse than death. An analysis of non-canonical texts like the Book of Enoch offers a terrifying example in the fate of the mothers of the Nephilim.
According to this interpretation, after these human women consorted with fallen angels and gave birth to giant, monstrous offspring, they were not granted the mercy of death in the Great Flood. Instead, they were transformed into Sirens. This was not an act of salvation but a form of "ontological damnation." Their biological existence was preserved, but their personhood, their identity, and their moral agency were annihilated. They were forced to survive as living weapons, forever embodying the very corruption they helped unleash.
The sirens become living monuments to transgression, eternal embodiments of the corruption they participated in. They survived the flood not through divine mercy but as instruments of divine justice, their continued existence serving purposes entirely external to their own welfare.
The horror of this concept lies in its inversion of mercy. To be punished not with oblivion, but with a cursed and compulsory continuation. To be forced to exist as a shell, a living "monument to transgression," trapped in a state of perpetual corruption and serving a purpose entirely outside of yourself. It suggests a form of divine justice so severe that it makes a swift end seem like a blessing.
3. The Systems That Promise Salvation Are Secretly Enslaving You
A potent and recurring theme is the deep paranoia that our institutions of safety and order are secretly corrupt. These stories suggest that the systems promising a cure are often the source of the disease, perpetuating the very problems they claim to solve in order to maintain control.
In A Scanner Darkly, the company New-Path is the sole provider of rehabilitation for addicts of the deadly "Substance D." The twist is that New-Path is also the secret organization responsible for growing, manufacturing, and distributing the drug in the first place. They create the addicts they pretend to save. This moral horror is laid bare in a conversation between two characters discussing the fate of the protagonist, who has been unknowingly sacrificed to this system:
"Yeah, but to sacrifice someone? A living person, without them ever knowing it? I mean, if he'd understood, if he had volunteered... but he doesn't know and he never did. He didn't volunteer for this." "Sure he did. It was his job." "It wasn't his job to get addicted. We took care of that."
This idea of a malevolent institution masquerading as a benevolent one appears elsewhere. In the film The Devil's Advocate, the protagonist joins a prestigious law firm that he believes is a bastion of justice, only to discover it's run by John Milton (Satan) as an elaborate machine for corrupting human souls. This fictional paranoia is mirrored in modern conspiracy theories, such as one source which claims that governments and powerful organizations use the threat of pandemics and financial instability as a "potent tool used to manipulate the masses" and impose greater control.
This theme is so powerful because it taps into a deep-seated fear that the systems we depend on—for rehabilitation, for justice, for security—are not safety nets, but cages in disguise. This anxiety feels particularly resonant today, echoing a modern distrust of sprawling, opaque systems, from pharmaceutical giants and their profit motives to governmental bodies that seem to expand their authority in times of crisis. The stories suggest our saviors might just be the architects of our suffering.
4. Your Favorite Song Might Be a Message from Another Realm
Artistic genius is often seen as the pinnacle of human expression. But what if it wasn't human at all? A persistent idea found in the internet's occult corners is that true creative genius, particularly in music, has a supernatural—and often demonic—source.
One YouTube video, "Michael Jackson: The Deception Behind His DARK Magic," argues that the King of Pop was not just a musician but a "powerful channeler and sorcerer." It claims his hit songs were not written but received through witchcraft. The video details three alleged methods: channeling the spirit of Liberace in a secret room of mirrors, receiving songs in dreams channeled from Morpheus (the god of dreams), and calling directly on "demonic spirits." This reframes his musical output not as art, but as occult ritual.
This idea is not limited to Jackson. Bob Dylan famously gave an interview that has become a cornerstone of this theory, where he alludes to a mysterious pact made long ago:
"Well, it goes back to the destiny thing. You know, I made a bargain with it, you know, a long time ago. And I'm holding up my end." "What was your bargain?" "To get to where I am now." "Should I ask who you made the bargain with?" "With, with, with, you know, with the chief, uh, chief commander. On this earth. And in a world we can't see."
The theory even deconstructs seemingly benevolent works. The lyrics to "We Are the World" are presented as demonic, specifically the line "As God has shown us by turning stones to bread," which is interpreted as a satanic suggestion—something Jesus would have done only if he had "obeyed Satan." The appeal of this idea is clear: it transforms artistic inspiration from a mysterious human process into a supernatural transaction, a gift from another realm that comes with a hidden, and perhaps terrible, cost.
5. Reality is a Hallucination You Can No Longer Control
The final, and perhaps most unsettling, idea is that our perception of reality itself is fundamentally untrustworthy. It could be a shared delusion, a drug-induced dream, or a computer simulation—and we have no way of knowing for sure.
This fear is captured perfectly in Flow My Tears, the Policeman Said. After his identity is erased, Jason Taverner is given a strange drug by a woman named Alys Buckman, and he suddenly begins to remember his celebrity life again. This prompts a terrifying realization:
What happened, Jason Taverner thought, is that the drug wore off. She—somebody—stopped giving it to me and I woke up to reality, there in that shabby, broken-down hotel room with the cracked mirror and the bug-infested mattress. And I stayed that way until now, until Alys gave me another dose.
He is confronted with the shocking possibility that his entire successful career was nothing more than a "retroactive hallucination created by the drug," and his real life was that of a derelict on skid row. The novel's epilogue reinforces this by describing a fictional drug, KR-3, which "breaks down the brain's ability to exclude one unit of space out of another," forcing the user to perceive "irreal universes."
This concept has evolved in the digital age. One blog, fittingly titled "The Chronically Online Algorithm," is described as a "living archive" reflecting a mind processing a "constant, high-volume stream of digital information." This creates a state where the lines between external data and internal reality begin to blur, turning a person's consciousness into a reflection of the algorithm. In an age of digital saturation, powerful psychotropic substances, and simulated realities, the fear that our own consciousness is an unreliable narrator is more potent than ever.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion: The Stories We Tell Ourselves
Each of these five ideas, drawn from a chaotic mix of fiction and online fringe theories, points to a common thread: a profound anxiety about the stability of identity, reality, and free will in the modern world. We fear that our sense of self can be deleted, that our systems of control are secretly enslaving us, and that our very perception of the world is a hallucination.
These stories function as a new kind of folklore, expressing the deepest fears of a society grappling with forces—technological, political, and pharmacological—that feel beyond its control. It leaves us with a final, thought-provoking question: If these disparate stories—from sci-fi novels to YouTube conspiracies—are the new folklore of our digital age, what does it mean that so many of them are about the terror of losing ourselves completely?
